At a glance
| Applies to | Uttar Pradesh. Orders of State departments, development authorities, UPSIDA, the Pollution Control Board and municipal corporations against a business |
|---|---|
| Law | Constitution of India, Article 226; Uttar Pradesh Procurement Manual (Procurement of Goods), 2016; GeM Incident Management Policy; Uttar Pradesh Industrial Area Development Act, 1976; Uttar Pradesh Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973; Water Act, 1974 and Air Act, 1981; National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; Uttar Pradesh Municipal Corporation Act, 1959 |
| First step | Usually the statutory remedy the order's own law provides: a reply to a show cause notice, an objection, an appeal or a restoration application |
| Common time limits | 5 or 10 calendar days on GeM; 30 days for most statutory appeals; 30 days for UPSIDA restoration; 15 days for a property tax appeal |
| High Court | Allahabad High Court, Lucknow Bench, for a cause of action arising wholly or in part in the Oudh areas |
First, see which law the order was passed under
When a government body acts against a business, the order usually names the law under which it was passed. That law often gives a first remedy, which may be a reply to a show cause notice, an objection, an appeal or a restoration application, and each carries a short time limit. If the limit is missed, the first remedy may close.
This page sets out the first remedy for orders that small factories, MSMEs and contractors in and around Lucknow commonly face, and when a writ petition under Article 226 is still an option.
Blacklisting or a ban on business dealings by a UP department
Under the Uttar Pradesh Procurement Manual (Procurement of Goods), in force from 1 April 2016, business dealings with a firm may be ordered suspended or banned in public interest by the competent authority (paragraph 6.17). Suspension is used while a full enquiry is pending (paragraph 6.18). The grounds for banning in paragraph 6.19 include conviction for an offence involving moral turpitude in relation to business dealings, strong justification for believing the firm has been guilty of malpractice such as bribery, corruption or fraud, and continued refusal to return government dues without adequate cause.
Paragraph 6.20 says: “A show cause notice shall be served to the firm/company before final orders are issued.” The list of firms blacklisted or banned is displayed on the website of the State Purchase Organisation. Under paragraph 6.5 a firm against whom punitive action has been taken is not eligible for re-registration for three years, or as prescribed.
Two further routes appear in the same Manual. Paragraph 18.6(5) says a bidder shall not be debarred unless given a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and debarment under paragraphs 18.6(2) to (4) can run up to three years. Clause 7 of the Integrity Pact annexure gives a right of appeal, within 30 days of the order of the State Purchase Organisation or the procuring entity, to the Principal Secretary or Secretary, MSME, Government of Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow, with the order remaining in force meanwhile unless that authority directs otherwise. Chapter 17 deals with grievances during the procurement process, on an application within 10 days, but does not mention banning or blacklisting.
On the show cause notice, the Supreme Court in UMC Technologies Pvt Ltd v. Food Corporation of India (Civil Appeal 3687 of 2020, decided 16 November 2020) held that a prior show cause notice giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard is an essential element of administrative decision-making, and particularly so in blacklisting, which the Court described as carrying long-lasting civil consequences; failure to furnish a valid notice “would be fatal to any order of blacklisting pursuant thereto”. The Court also held that the notice must spell out clearly, or allow it to be clearly inferred, that the issuer intends to blacklist, and that the mere existence of a clause in the bid document mentioning blacklisting does not satisfy that requirement.
Three things to check on the order itself: whether a show cause notice was served, whether it said blacklisting was proposed, and whether a hearing was given before the final order.
Suspension or debarment on GeM
Under the GeM Incident Management Policy in force from 1 April 2024, a show cause notice is issued on an incident and must be responded to, or corrective action taken, within 5 calendar days. If the notice is not answered even 10 days after it is sent, the system acts on its own. Suspension periods run from 30 days for a mild deviation up to 365 days for a grave one, and may be extended up to two years with the approval of the Chief Marketplace Officer.
The appeal under clause 8 can be made only after a penalty is imposed, within 10 calendar days of the penalty, once per incident, and only where there is additional material evidence that was not before the competent authority. Status does not change while the appeal is under consideration. That appeal does not apply to debarment by a Ministry or by the Department of Expenditure, which is taken up offline with the buyer organisation.
UPSIDA plot cancellation
Under section 14 of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Area Development Act, 1976, on non-payment of consideration money or an instalment, breach of a condition of transfer, or breach of rules or regulations, the Chief Executive Officer may resume the site or building and may forfeit the whole or part of the money paid, and the Collector may, on requisition, cause possession to be delivered.
The UPSIDA Operating Manual for Industrial Areas 2023 sets out three grounds of cancellation: non-payment of dues, non-utilisation, and breach of other conditions of the allotment letter, licence agreement or lease deed. Each requires notice before action, and the officer must satisfy himself that the default notice was served. For non-utilisation the notice is 30 days, or 60 days to the financial institution and the lessee where the lease stands transferred to a financial institution.
On restoration, an application is considered up to 30 days from the date of cancellation and only if the plot has not been allotted to someone else; it is considered only in favour of the entity that was the allottee at cancellation; the entire outstanding dues up to the date of cancellation must be paid, along with the restoration levy and processing fee; and restoration is not considered where a court of law has passed orders in favour of the Authority in a suit filed by the ex-allottee. Re-allotment to another needs the cancellation letter served, re-entry made where applicable, at least 30 days elapsed from cancellation, and no restoration representation pending.
Separately, section 12 of the 1976 Act applies section 41 of the Uttar Pradesh Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973 to the Authority. Section 41(3) lets the State Government, at any time, on its own motion or on an application, call for the records of a case disposed of or an order passed by the Authority or the Chairman and pass such order as it thinks fit, after giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard before passing an order prejudicial to any person.
Section 16-B of the 1976 Act, on user charges, gives an appeal to an Appellate Authority nominated by the State Government within 90 days of receipt of the assessment order, to be decided within six months, and that order is final.
Pollution Control Board directions and consent orders
Section 33A of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and section 31A of the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 both let a Board issue binding written directions, and both say expressly that this includes the power to direct closure, prohibition or regulation of any industry, operation or process, and the stoppage or regulation of supply of electricity, water or any other service.
- Water Act consent orders, under sections 25, 26 and 27: appeal under section 28 within 30 days from communication of the order, to the appellate authority constituted by the State Government; delay may be condoned for sufficient cause.
- Air Act: appeal under section 31 against an order made by the State Board under that Act, within 30 days from communication, to the appellate authority constituted by the State Government; delay may be condoned.
- Then to the National Green Tribunal under section 16 of the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010, within 30 days of communication, with a further 60 days possible for sufficient cause. Section 16 covers a decision of the Water Act section 28 appellate authority, a direction issued under section 33A of the Water Act, and a decision of the Air Act section 31 appellate authority. A direction under section 31A of the Air Act is not in the section 16 list.
- From the Tribunal, appeal to the Supreme Court under section 22 within 90 days of communication, on the grounds in section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Section 29 bars civil courts from entertaining appeals in matters within the Tribunal's appellate jurisdiction.
Property tax and sealing
Under the Uttar Pradesh Municipal Corporation Act, 1959, an appeal against the annual value or the tax fixed or charged lies to “the Judge”, that is the Judge of the Court of Small Causes having jurisdiction in the city. Section 472(2) says the appeal will not be heard unless it is brought within 15 days after the cause of complaint accrued, the earlier objection has been made and disposed of, and, where a bill has been presented, the amount claimed has been deposited with the Mukhya Nagar Adhikari. Section 473 fixes when the cause of complaint accrues, generally the day the objection is disposed of, or for other taxes the day payment is demanded or the bill served. Under section 500(1), sections 5, 12 and 14 of the Limitation Act apply to computing the period.
A further appeal lies to the District Judge under section 476, but only where the annual value fixed is above twelve thousand rupees, or on a question of law or of usage having the force of law or the construction of a document, and only if filed within one month of the decision.
Section 503 lists how a Corporation tax may be recovered: by presenting a bill, by a written notice of demand, by distraint and sale of movable property, by attachment and sale of immovable property, in the case of property tax by attachment of rent due in respect of the property, and by a suit.
On sealing by a development authority, under section 28-A of the Uttar Pradesh Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973 the Vice-Chairman, or an officer empowered by him, may order the sealing of an unauthorised development at any time before or after an order under section 27 or 28; the seal may be removed only under an order under section 28-A(2); and an appeal lies to the Chairman within 30 days from the date of the order, the Chairman's decision being final. A demolition order under section 27(1), which itself requires a reasonable opportunity to show cause, may be appealed to the Chairman within 30 days under section 27(2); the Chairman may stay execution, and the decision is final and not open to question in any court.
When the High Court may hear a writ although another remedy exists
Article 226(1) of the Constitution gives every High Court power to issue directions, orders and writs for the enforcement of the rights in Part III and for any other purpose. Article 226(2) allows the High Court within whose territory the cause of action arises wholly or in part to exercise that power even though the authority sits outside that territory.
The High Court normally expects the statutory remedy to be used first. In Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks, Mumbai (Supreme Court, 26 October 1998) the Court said the alternative remedy has consistently been held not to operate as a bar in at least three contingencies: where the writ petition is filed for the enforcement of a fundamental right, where there has been a violation of the principle of natural justice, or where the order or proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction or the vires of an Act is challenged.
Under Article 226(3), where an interim order is made without the other party being given copies of the petition and supporting documents and an opportunity of being heard, that party may apply to vacate it, and the High Court is to dispose of the application within two weeks of receipt or of the copy being furnished, whichever is later; if it is not disposed of in that period, the interim order stands vacated.
Lucknow Bench or Allahabad
In Nasiruddin v. State Transport Appellate Tribunal (Supreme Court, 29 August 1975) the Court held that where the cause of action arises wholly or in part at a place within the specified Oudh areas, the Lucknow Bench will have jurisdiction; where it arises wholly within those areas, the Lucknow Bench has exclusive jurisdiction; and where it arises only in part within them, the litigant, being dominus litis, may choose the forum, with the Court deciding in each case whether its jurisdiction is rightly attracted.
The same judgment records that the territories historically comprised in Oudh were the twelve districts of Lucknow, Faizabad, Sultanpur, Rai Bareli, Pratapgarh, Barabanki, Gonda, Bahraich, Sitapur, Kheri, Hardoi and Unnao. Many of these have since been reorganised, so which bench a particular matter goes to is worked out case by case from where the cause of action arose.
Order, first remedy and time limit
| Order | First remedy | Time limit | When a writ may be argued |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blacklisting or ban by a UP department (Procurement Manual) | Reply to the show cause notice required by paragraph 6.20; where the Integrity Pact applies, appeal to the Principal Secretary, MSME | As stated in the notice; Integrity Pact appeal 30 days | No notice, notice silent on blacklisting, or no hearing |
| GeM suspension or debarment | Reply to the show cause notice; appeal under clause 8 after a penalty | 5 calendar days to reply; appeal 10 calendar days, once per incident | Natural justice or want of jurisdiction |
| UPSIDA cancellation | Restoration application under the 2023 Manual; separately, section 41(3) of the 1973 Act via section 12 | 30 days from cancellation, if not re-allotted | Natural justice or want of jurisdiction |
| UPSIDA user charges assessment | Appeal to the Appellate Authority, section 16-B | 90 days from receipt of the order | Natural justice or want of jurisdiction |
| UPPCB consent order (Water Act ss.25 to 27) | Appeal to the appellate authority, Water Act section 28 | 30 days from communication, delay condonable | Then the NGT under section 16; a writ is the exception |
| UPPCB order under the Air Act | Appeal to the appellate authority, Air Act section 31 | 30 days from communication, delay condonable | Then the NGT under section 16 |
| Closure direction, Water Act section 33A | Appeal to the National Green Tribunal, section 16 | 30 days, further 60 days for sufficient cause | The NGT is the statutory route |
| Property tax or annual value | Objection, then appeal to the Judge of the Court of Small Causes, section 472 | 15 days from accrual, with deposit where a bill is presented | Natural justice or want of jurisdiction |
| Sealing by a development authority | Appeal to the Chairman, section 28-A | 30 days from the date of the order | Natural justice or want of jurisdiction |
| Demolition order, section 27(1) | Appeal to the Chairman, section 27(2) | 30 days from the date of the order | Natural justice or want of jurisdiction |
Rajesh Kumar Tripathi & Associates, MIG-208, Phase 1, T.R.T. L.D.A. Colony, Rajajipuram, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh 226017
Phone: +91 94504 47257 (Mon–Fri, 10:00–17:30) · Email: officerktassociates@gmail.com · online form
Frequently asked questions
What does the law say where a blacklisting order comes without any show cause notice?
Paragraph 6.20 of the Uttar Pradesh Procurement Manual requires a show cause notice before final orders are issued. In UMC Technologies (16 November 2020) the Supreme Court held that failure to furnish a valid show cause notice would be fatal to an order of blacklisting passed on it, and that the notice must make the proposed blacklisting clear.
How long is the appeal window on GeM?
Ten calendar days from the imposition of the penalty, once per incident, and only where there is additional material evidence that was not before the competent authority. The show cause notice itself has to be answered within 5 calendar days.
A UPSIDA plot has been cancelled. What is the deadline?
Under the UPSIDA Operating Manual 2023 an application for restoration is considered up to 30 days from the date of cancellation, and only if the plot has not been allotted to someone else. The outstanding dues up to the date of cancellation, the restoration levy and the processing fee are payable.
Where does an appeal against a UPPCB closure direction go?
A direction under section 33A of the Water Act is appealable to the National Green Tribunal under section 16 of the National Green Tribunal Act, within 30 days of communication, with a further 60 days possible for sufficient cause. Consent orders under sections 25 to 27 go first to the State appellate authority under section 28.
Does house tax have to be deposited before an appeal is heard?
Section 472(2) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipal Corporation Act, 1959 requires that, where a bill for the tax has been presented, the amount claimed has been deposited with the Mukhya Nagar Adhikari.
Lucknow Bench or Allahabad?
On the rule in Nasiruddin (1975), the Lucknow Bench has jurisdiction where the cause of action arises wholly or in part within the specified Oudh areas, and exclusive jurisdiction where it arises wholly within them. Where it arises only in part there, the petitioner, being dominus litis, may choose, and the Court decides in each case whether its jurisdiction is rightly attracted.
Related pages
- Legal matters for businesses in Lucknow
- SARFAESI 13(2) notice
- Commercial suits in Lucknow
- Writ matters (Lucknow Bench)
- Development authority matters (Lucknow)
- हाई कोर्ट में रिट याचिका कैसे दायर करें (Hindi)
- फ़ैक्ट्री लाइसेंस और लेबर कोड — UP 2026 (Hindi)
Sources: Constitution of India, Article 226; Nasiruddin v. State Transport Appellate Tribunal (Supreme Court, 29 August 1975); Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks, Mumbai (Supreme Court, 26 October 1998); UMC Technologies Pvt Ltd v. Food Corporation of India, Civil Appeal 3687 of 2020 (16 November 2020); Uttar Pradesh Procurement Manual (Procurement of Goods), 2016, paragraphs 6.5, 6.17 to 6.20, Chapter 17, paragraph 18.6 and the Integrity Pact annexure; GeM Incident Management Policy in force from 1 April 2024, clauses 3 and 8; Uttar Pradesh Industrial Area Development Act, 1976, sections 12, 14 and 16-B; UPSIDA Operating Manual for Industrial Areas, 2023, clauses 4.02 to 4.05 and Chapter 5; Uttar Pradesh Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973, sections 27, 28-A and 41; Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, sections 25 to 28 and 33A; Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, sections 31 and 31A; National Green Tribunal Act, 2010, sections 16, 22 and 29; Uttar Pradesh Municipal Corporation Act, 1959, sections 2(32), 472, 473, 476, 500 and 503. Last checked: 14 November 2026.